September 1, 2022
Ampersand Issue 10: A Universe Infused with Meaning
Editor’s Note: This fall, we’re delighted to welcome Dr. Arend J. (AJ) Poelarends onto the Anselm House team. AJ will direct our university engagement programs and further develop those initiatives into a new Center for Faith & Learning at Anselm House. Born and raised in the Netherlands, Dr. Poelarends holds a Ph.D. in Astrophysics from the University of Utrecht, where he became interested in cosmology from his desire to learn more about the universe and our place within it. This led him into further studies in theology, earning an M.Div from Covenant Seminary in St. Louis, MO. AJ comes to Anselm House most recently from Wheaton College in Illinois, where he was Associate Professor of Physics and Astronomy, and co-directed the Wheaton College Science Station in the Black Hills. In this Ampersand contribution, AJ shares what inspires and animates him as he brings his expertise into the Anselm House mission of connecting Christian faith with all areas of research and learning at the University of Minnesota. - Andrew Hansen, Program Director
For thousands of years people have been looking up to the stars above, and have often asked themselves deep questions: Why are we here? Are we alone in the universe? What is beyond the stars? Why are we so small in this vast universe? Is there something bigger? What is the meaning of it all? Raised in a Christian family, but confronted with serious challenges to my faith during my early college years, these very questions led me to pursue studies in astrophysics and theology to explore these issues in the most expansive way.
None of these questions are surprising. Indeed, it is almost as if we are made to ask these questions. For several years I have read Sean Carroll’s The Big Picture with my students at Wheaton College, where I worked the past 11 years. Carroll’s book explores who we are, where we come from, how we can understand ourselves, and whether it makes more sense to understand this reality in naturalistic terms or in theistic terms.
Sean Carroll is a naturalist, who believes that there is only one realm of reality: the material world, described by natural laws. However, he realizes that while this may make sense of the physical world, when you start thinking about life itself, consciousness, and especially morality, this claim becomes more challenging. He therefore suggests an extension of plain naturalism, which he calls ‘poetic naturalism’ which posits that there are various levels of reality, each with its own domain of applicability, and each with its own story to tell. While the story that physics tells is the most fundamental story, biology tells its own story, and so does psychology, and so does ethics—all of them emerging from the physical. Still, for Carroll it is the principles of physics that in the end give rise to and govern reality—the steady increase of entropy, the evolution of the quantum wavefunction as described by contemporary physical theories, and the persistent determinism of Hugh Everett’s Many World Hypothesis.
The story that Carroll tells is one where the complexity of human experience is reduced to electrical and chemical potential. Taken together, Carroll’s fundamental principles make any form of human free will ultimately illusory. Carroll’s story is one where human responsibility, morality and meaning is reduced to merely a secondary social construct––a story that may satisfy comfortable urban or suburban intellectuals, but whether it fits the search for meaning the slums of Rio or the Gulag Archipelago is doubtful.
For the past ten summers, I have taught an Astronomy course in the Black Hills of South Dakota in the middle of Lakota territory. Through a personal friendship with a Lakota pastor I gained a deeper appreciation for the Lakota worldview. In Lakota perspective, whatever happens on earth has a connection to the heavens. Their religious sites, positioned throughout and especially around Paha Sapa (the Black Hills) are mirrored in the heavens, in the Sacred Hoop, a shape similar to the winter hexagon in Western astronomy, but here dominated by the large Lakota constellation Tayamni and to a lesser extent by Mato Tipila (Gemini).
When certain stars became visible, Lakota bands would worship at the place that corresponds with the location on the Sacred Hoop, culminating with the Sun Dance ceremony during summer solstice at Mato Tipila or Bear Lodge (also known as Devils Tower). Connected with these religious ceremonies are the ancient origin stories of the Lakota people, the virtues ingrained in their culture, and the intimate interdependence of everything. But these ceremonies are also connected with various practical concerns, like agricultural and hunting practices. The intimate complexity of the Lakota worldview—a deep, rich interconnected tapestry of relationships, all infused with meaning—stands in stark contrast to the often sterile worldview of many Western people, and in even starker contrast to the sparse meaning of Carroll’s poetic naturalism.
As a Christian, I feel deep sympathy for the Lakota perspective, even though many elements of their beliefs feel foreign to me. One doesn’t have to agree with every facet to still maintain a ‘tender reverence’ for their rituals, beliefs, and practices as Lakota scholar Craig Howe says.
The Lakota worldview is deeply integrated and whole, connecting beliefs and practices with almost every living and non-living entity, in a way that is not entirely different from the Judeo-Christian worldview.
The Old Testament Psalms provide a window into the Jewish worldview, and it continues to shape Christian belief and worship today. For me, Psalm 19 has been central to my faith. In it, David develops a fascinating view on who God is and his relationship to creation and humanity–indeed, connecting faith in God to all of life.
In the first verse, he announces: “The heavens declare the glory of God, and the sky above proclaims his handiwork.” In the verses that follow, he develops an intimate worldview in which creation reveals and bears witness to its maker, speaking knowledge to all human hearts. While David speaks of God in very personal terms, it is important to note that creation itself is distinct from its creator, and not divine itself. Therefore the natural world as creation can and should be studied, and not just to know more about God.
In another Psalm David sings:
When I look at your heavens, the work of your fingers,
the moon and the stars, which you have set in place,
what is man that you are mindful of him,
and the son of man that you care for him? (ESV, Psalm 8:3-4)
It continues to amaze me that the questions David asked around 3,000 years ago remain our questions. Who are we? Why are we here? Are we alone in the universe? Is there someone who cares, and why?
If you are willing to go deeper, the questions become even more profound, especially at the interface of philosophy and science. How is it possible that we are even able to think about these questions, that we are able to comprehend the structure and shape of this universe, this reality? How is it possible that abstract mathematical models are the most appropriate way to describe physical reality? Is mathematics eternal or temporal, discovered or invented? What does it mean that we have a mind that can engage in both abstract and concrete thinking? What actually is a mind and how does it relate to the brain? Where does our innate sense of morality come from? Especially as we discover more about the staggering fine-tuning of our universe for life, the question is unavoidable. Who are we? Why are we here? The questions go on and on.
I love these kinds of questions, and will be asking them for the rest of my life––one reason that I’m so excited to help foster the pursuit of these kinds of questions at the University of Minnesota through Anselm House. Naturally, such questions transcend the Lakota worldview, but my recent encounters with the Lakota culture have helped me appreciate more deeply the connections between the natural world, the human world and the spiritual world, and to see everything as infused with wonder and meaning. This interconnectedness is often missing in modern science––and academic knowledge more generally–– where so much is disconnected and put in disciplinary boxes. Is there maybe more in the relationships than we think? Is the whole more than the parts? Is this world richer and thicker than the sciences alone can capture?
From a Christian perspective it makes sense. It is what we would expect. A personal God, existing in a triune relationship, is the author of a world that exhibits his character in many different ways: The fine-tuning of the universe for life; A mind that is attuned to this reality; The appropriateness of mathematics for the description of physical reality; An innate sense of right and wrong; A sense of awe and wonder when we look up to the skies.
None of this should surprise us—we are made to ask these questions and to discover more of this reality. And when we do, I’ve become more and more convinced that we are drawn toward God in the process, as has been beautifully captured by St. Anselm in the concluding prayer in his Proslogion:
Teach me to seek You.
I cannot seek You unless You teach me
or find You unless You show Yourself to me.
Let me seek You in my desire,
let me desire You in my seeking.
Let me find You by loving You,
let me love You when I find You.
1. I resonate with Albert Einstein when he said: "The most incomprehensible thing about the universe is that it is comprehensible" (Physics and Reality, 1936).
Subscribe to Ampersand
Thoughtful and diverse content delivered to your inbox.